One of the biggest tax advantages of an S corporation is that an S corporation shareholder’s share of business income generally isn’t subject to self-employment tax. By contrast, shareholder-employees pay FICA (Social Security and Medicare) taxes and other applicable payroll taxes on their wages. That distinction can produce significant tax savings, but it also makes the amount of compensation paid to shareholder-employees an important issue.

The basics

S corporation owners may be tempted to take minimal salaries or even forgo salaries altogether to avoid payroll taxes. They instead take money out of the business in the form of distributions, which generally aren’t subject to payroll taxes and may be tax-free to the extent of the shareholder’s stock basis. But this practice is risky.

The reasonable compensation issue generally arises when a shareholder performs services for the corporation and receives or is entitled to payments from it. If a shareholder receives or has the right to receive cash or property, the corporation must determine and report an appropriate reasonable salary for services performed before treating amounts as nonwage distributions. Businesses that fail to do so may be subject to substantial back taxes, penalties and interest.

Another important consideration is how low salaries may affect a business’s eligibility for other tax benefits. (See “Beyond payroll taxes: How wages affect other tax breaks.”)

The rules in practice

Here’s an example that illustrates the issue. Bruce is the sole owner and employee of E-Street Enterprises, Inc., an S corporation that generates $250,000 in taxable income per year before considering Bruce’s compensation. To avoid payroll taxes, the corporation pays Bruce no salary and distributes $250,000 to him. Before considering Bruce’s compensation, the corporation has $250,000 of taxable income that generally passes through to Bruce. Assuming Bruce has sufficient stock basis, the distribution itself is nontaxable.

On audit, the IRS recharacterizes $100,000 of the distribution as wages, finding that amount to be a reasonable salary for Bruce’s services. The reclassified wages are subject to federal employment taxes in addition to applicable income taxes. Bruce and the business must each pay FICA taxes equal to 7.65% of Bruce’s salary — 6.2% in Social Security taxes and 1.45% in Medicare taxes. (In 2026, the Social Security tax applies to the first $184,500 in wages, while the Medicare tax applies to all wages.) Each pays $7,650, for a total FICA tax burden of $15,300, plus penalties and interest. The business may also owe other employment taxes, such as federal and state unemployment taxes. Note that the business’s share of payroll taxes is deductible by the S corporation as a business expense, reducing Bruce’s pass-through income and partially offsetting the increased payroll tax burden.

Determining reasonable compensation

There’s no specific formula for calculating reasonable compensation. Rather, the IRS analyzes all of the facts and circumstances, weighing factors such as:

  • The employee’s training and experience,
  • The employee’s duties and responsibilities,
  • The time and effort the employee devotes to the business,
  • The business’s dividend history,
  • Compensation paid to nonshareholder employees,
  • The timing and manner of bonuses paid to key people,
  • What comparable businesses pay for similar services,
  • Compensation agreements, and
  • The use of a formula to determine compensation.

To reduce the risk of an IRS challenge, S corporations should analyze shareholder-employee compensation. Begin by evaluating shareholder salaries in light of the above factors and document their reasonableness using industry data and information about the business’s activities and finances. Useful sources of industry data include compensation surveys and industry statistics (such as ratios of average compensation to sales or profits). With this information, an S corporation can provide IRS auditors with a well-documented roadmap showing the reasonableness of shareholder salaries.

Be proactive

S corporations offer valuable tax advantages, but it’s important not to push them too far. By proactively evaluating shareholder-employee salaries based on relevant facts and circumstances, benchmarking them against industry statistics and compensation surveys, and documenting the analysis, businesses can make the most of S corporation status. Doing so may reduce the risk of an IRS challenge and strengthen their position in the event of an examination. A tax advisor can help evaluate reasonable compensation and its tax implications.

Beyond payroll taxes: How wages affect other tax breaks

To minimize payroll taxes, many S corporations pay shareholder-employees the lowest possible salaries that still qualify as reasonable. But paying the bare minimum may reduce other tax benefits.

For example, the Section 199A qualified business income (QBI) deduction allows owners of S corporations and other pass-through entities to deduct up to 20% of certain business income. But for 2026, certain QBI limitations begin to phase in when taxable income exceeds $201,750 for single filers and $403,500 for married couples filing jointly. The phase-in ranges end at $276,750 and $553,500, respectively. Once those income levels are reached, the deduction may be limited based on W-2 wages paid by the business and the unadjusted basis of certain qualified property. Additional limitations apply to specified service trades or businesses. So, when setting salaries, it’s important to balance the potential payroll tax savings of lower (but reasonable) salaries against the potential loss of QBI benefits.

Another important consideration is shareholders’ ability to contribute to 401(k) plans or other employer-sponsored retirement plans. For shareholder-employees, 401(k) contributions are generally based on W-2 compensation, not S corporation distributions. Similarly, employer contributions are based on eligible compensation, not shareholder distributions. When setting shareholder-employee salaries, S corporations should balance potential payroll tax savings against potential losses in tax-advantaged retirement plan contributions.

© 2026

Icon for Thompson Greenspon
Thompson Greenspon

This blog post was provided by Thompson Greenspon. If you have questions or concerns regarding this content, please contact us.